Journal article

The Fallacy of Multiple Methods

Year:

2015

Published in:

Comparative Politics Newsletter

Authors:

comparative politics
methodological diversity
logical fallacies
causal relationships
experimental research

Political scientists are trained to identify logical fallacies, yet as a subfield, comparativists have fallen victim to a pernicious failure of reasoning, one that I will call the fallacy of multiple methods. The fallacy goes like this: Comparative politics maximizes its understanding of the political world when multiple methods are employed; therefore, graduate students in comparative politics should produce work that employs multiple methods. To understand why this is a fallacy, it is helpful to unpack the argument into its constituent parts.The premise of the statement, in my view, is on firm ground. Ethnographic and interpretive work offers deep insight into the motivations and understandings of particular political actors. Statistics gives us the tools to make statements of more or less confidence about populations of political actors or governing entities. Experimental research identifies causal relationships that are otherwise difficult or impossible to observe. Game theory provides a language for understanding the strategic interaction that is often central to politics. One could go on. The point is that the diversity of methods in comparative politics exists for a reason.

Related by author

50 publications found

2014
Analytical article

A Way Forward For Ukraine

Publisher: International Herald Tribune

Authors: Tymofiy Mylovanov, Scott Gehlbach, Roger Myerson

2023
Working paper

War, Collateral Damage, And Firm‑Level Consequences

Publisher: World Bank Group

Authors: Solomiya Shpak, John S. Earle, Scott Gehlbach, Mariia Panga

2019
Working paper

Preventing Predation: Oligarchs, Obfuscation, And Political Connections

Publisher: SSRN

Authors: Solomiya Shpak, John S. Earle, Scott Gehlbach, Anton Shirikov

2019
Working paper

Obfuscating Ownership

Publisher: The National Science Foundation

Authors: Solomiya Shpak, John S. Earle, Scott Gehlbach, Anton Shirikov

2018
Journal article

Property Rights In Post‑Soviet Russia: Violence, Corruption, And The Demand For Law

Publisher: Post-Soviet Affairs

Authors: Scott Gehlbach

2023
Journal article

Damaged Collateral And Firm‑Level Finance: Evidence From Russia’s War In Ukraine

Publisher: Journal of Comparative Economics

Authors: Solomiya Shpak, John S. Earle, Scott Gehlbach, Mariia Panga

2021
Working paper

The Oligarch Vanishes: Defensive Ownership, Property Rights, And Political Connections

Publisher: SSRN

Authors: Solomiya Shpak, John S. Earle, Anton Shirikov, Scott Gehlbach

2025
Journal article

Is there really a dictator's dilemma? Information and repression in autocracy

Publisher: American Journal of Political Science

Authors: Scott Gehlbach, Dmitriy Vorobyev, Anton Shirikov, Zhaotian Luo

2025
Journal article

Private Investment and the Institutionalization of Collective Action in Autocracies: Ruling Parties and Legislatures

Publisher: Japanese Journal of Political Science

Authors: Scott Gehlbach, Philip Keefer

2022
Book Chapter

Who Reports Crime? Citizen Engagement with the Police in Russia and Georgia

Publisher: Routledge

Authors: Scott Gehlbach, Noah Buckley, Lauren A. McCarthy, Timothy Frye