On ‘Average’
Year:
2009Published in:
MindThis article investigates the semantics of sentences that express numerical averages, focusing initially on cases such as ‘The average American has 2.3 children’. Such sentences have been used both by linguists and philosophers to argue for a disjuncture between semantics and ontology. For example, Noam Chomsky and Norbert Hornstein have used them to provide evidence against the hypothesis that natural language semantics includes a reference relation holding between words and objects in the world, whereas metaphysicians such as Joseph Melia and Stephen Yablo have used them to provide evidence that apparent singular reference need not be taken as ontologically committing. We develop a fully general and independently justified compositional semantics in which such constructions are assigned truth conditions that are not ontologically problematic, and show that our analysis is superior to all extant rivals. Our analysis provides evidence that a good semantics yields a sensible ontology. It also reveals that natural language contains genuine singular terms that refer to numbers.
Related by author
56 publications found
The Politics Of Language
Publisher: Princeton University Press
Authors: Jason Stanley, David Beaver
Propaganda
Publisher: Routledge
Authors: Jason Stanley, Anne Quaranto
How Propaganda Works
Publisher: Princeton University Press
Authors: Jason Stanley
Banning Ideas And Authors Is Not A ‘Culture War’ – It’s Fascism
Publisher: The Guardian
Authors: Jason Stanley
How Fascism Works: The Politics Of Us And Them
Publisher: Random House
Authors: Jason Stanley
Rationality Is Gendered
Publisher: Collabra: Psychology
Authors: Jason Stanley, Yarrow Dunham, Olivia Pavco-Giaccia, Martha Fitch Little
In Defense Of Truth, And The Threat Of Disinformation
Publisher: United States Advisory Commission
Authors: Jason Stanley
We Disagree On A Lot Of Things. Except The Danger Of Anti‑Critical Race Theory Laws.
Publisher: International New York Times
Authors: Jason Stanley, David French, Kmele Foster, Thomas Chatterton Williams
Knowledge And Practical Interests
Publisher: Oxford University Press
Authors: Jason Stanley
Modality And What Is Said
Publisher: Philosophical Perspectives
Authors: Jason Stanley